Islam Cannot Stop USA Publishing The Jewel of Medina

epoxsam

i agree there’s a lot of historical fact in it and it speaks highly of the personality of prophet Muhammad (pbuh). but where did she got this secret affair thing between aisha (r.a) and safwan mu’attal? and that aisha kissed him??!!! mother of the believers who deeply in love with her husband that she could stare him for hours watching his sweat glistening thru the sun and then recite a love poem to him shortly after just to portray that moment??!!

This book is very dangerous because it is trying to make sense of a history through modern, hollywood-styled mentality. i view this book as an anti-muslim effort of demonizing Islam thru a slow, sleazy, poisoning way.. as if the devil himself inspired it.

mikontisot

Which is fine that is your opinion. I on the other hand would like to read it. there is no such thing as a “bad” book, it is how one reacts that gives a book it’s power. Mein Kampf is really quite infantile, but look what happened when it came with all the bells and gongs with it? I would suggest there re alot more books out there that are more dangerous than a novel.

MohummedsM8

epoxsam, I see it another way… the devil himself inspired Islam, and this books starts to expose it

epoxsam

What freedom of speech? this novel is a fiction version of a history. the depiction of aisha (r.a) was perverted with hollywood style mind-set. and bulding bridges between Islam and the west by re-inventing innocent and pure history through sleazy novel is a SCANDAL!!

andreaandrewmilne

Dear epoxsam,

What arguments do you have to justify the claim that it is “very dangerous” to “demonise Islam”? In what way could it be dangerous to crticise a thought system, unless you mean that the fanatical adherents of this ideology will get annoyed at the slightest criticism, and thereby leap at the pretext to:

(i) demand restrictions on freedom of expression,

(ii) scream for ever more repressive control of XX people

(iii) shout for the execution of non-heterosexual and polyamourous people

(iv) cut people’s throats, especially film makers who reveal the patriarchal sexual sadism within Islam

(iv) fly planes into skyscrapers and set off explosives on public transport,

and in general do all that is possible to threaten liberal individualism, whilst demanding liberal tolerance so as to propagate the same fascistic Islamic Ideology. A cunning tactic, but very unattractive.

It would be dangerous not to ridicule Islam by every means possible. Basically, the world has suffered enough from the tyranny of patriarchal Abrahamic monotheism. It is time for an atheist, feminist, erotic-positive and scientific-minded world, based on love and creativity.

andrea